Would like to point out this when you got banned - you said you RECENTLY got the hack before YOU got banned for it and that you never had it; which also makes me jump to my next conclusion, yes he may have tried it and it may have 'worked', but all I see from this is that:
- You tried to lie your way out in the appeal - saw it being declined and reported Sam out of despise and seeing it being unjust
- You said you never tried it nor had it before but apparently you did and you even sent it to Sam? Which makes it even worse for your case if you EVER wanted to appeal.
- Again and I repeat myself, if Sam actually used it in a room with YOU, do you have the evidence of him using it in-game?