Mesh Contest Scores

Rubric for Grading:

Spoiler!

Voting: 50 points possible; based on percentage of votes received
Mesh: 20 points possible; Based on topology, usage of faces, rendering tools, and creativity.
Texture: 15 points possible; Based on UV mapping and the ability to use a texture on a mesh.
Concept: 10 points possible; Does the piece display a point or theme or is it simply confusing?
Contest Specific: 10 points possible; Does the piece fit the contest?

Deductions: 5 points for unfinished, up to 15 points for failing to meet requirements

Week I: Make a Weapon
Winner: Slugheady
Total points earned*: 75

Voting: 26/50 Points; 52.50% of the votes
Mesh: 18/20; Check vertex density of the ribbon as well as a few weird quads at the bottom of the spear head
Texture: 11/15; UV mapping nicely done, needs more variation throughout, add scratches and reevaluate base texture
Concept: 10/10; No grading notes
Contest Specific: 10/10; No grading notes

Other Participants:

Spoiler!

Zain: 55 (5 Points from voting; 5 point deduction for unfinished)
Google: 51 (8 Points from voting)
Wucas: 46 (11 Points from voting; 5 point deduction for unfinished)

Week II - III: Bag o' Textures
Winner: Nagi
Total points earned*: 89

Voting: 50/50 points (by default, no other participants)
Mesh: 19/20; Vertex density is 3x greater in the dirt than in the rest of the piece
Texture: */15; no grading notes
Concept: 10/10; No grading notes
Contest Specific: 10/10; No grading notes

Other Participants:

Spoiler!

None

*Points are irrelative between separate challenges; they should not be a value in which to compare two winners of separate weeks, they are only there to compare one project to another in the same setting.