Suggestion Regarding Completed Reports

Suggestion type: Forum

Suggestion title: Completed Hacker/Player & Forum Reports

Suggestion description:

I don't see the logic in allowing us to see completed hacker/player reports, but not allowing us to see completed forum reports. I say either make it so we can see both or make it so we can see neither. Unban/Unwarn appeals makes sense that we shouldn't see, since it's none of the public's business anyway and it's something settled between that individual and the staff. But I personally think we should be able to see both completed hacker/player reports and the completed forum reports as well. Even though the report isn't really any of the public's business, you could be the person being reported. It would be nice to see a thorough, detailed reason why someone reported you, so that should their report be accepted, you can compile a thorough unban/unwarn appeal. One with reasonable counter arguments to defend yourself in regards to the things they said and the evidence they provided.

Yay or nay ? '-'

Agree, that actually makes sense lol.

Never really thought about this and i dont mind eitherway, though i would prefer that users not see anything because as you said; its not their business.

no because i report my friends without them knowing

As curious as I might be, I also think you shouldnt be able to see neither. Infact, I think it would help if you didnt see the reports because when you get to see who reported you, you might just behave around that guy, and still act like a douche when he's gone.

I actually think that people would be more careful overall when they decide to go "keyboard warrior mode".

The only reason completed FGunZ reports are public is because when GM's add a warning to a FGunZ account, the evidence is displayed at http://fgunz.net/account and if the section is private, people will not be able to see the evidence.

Also a fan of not being able to see reports

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Suggestive

Also a fan of not being able to see reports

---

Why not? Why would you need access to reports about other people?

"Not being able to see reports" -> I think we as players shouldn't be able to see completed reports. Not sure if that's how you understood it.

I also am skeptical if players should see the evidence against them at all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Suggestive

"Not being able to see reports" -> I think we as players shouldn't be able to see completed reports. Not sure if that's how you understood it.

I also am skeptical if players should see the evidence against them at all.

---

Ah like that.
Well we wanted to make it completely private in a way like a tickets system, but that will probably be too complicated for people and we want to keep reporting as simple as possible.

Well, with the new website being worked on and such... would there be a way for a player to see the evidence against them (at the link you posted above) while restricting others from viewing it? Maybe that is a decent compromise.

I'm personally with others on this in that I don't like people seeing what I report for or with what evidence and what characters etc..

Maybe instead of making it all public to everyone, like Suggestive said, find a way to attach the report to that individual being reported ? I don't know how it would work for the in-game reports, but for forum reports, maybe when the person enters the user's forum name, have them enter it into a text box, then as they go entering letters, a list of names will appear until it narrows down to that user, then they can click on the user's name (I know I worded that confusingly, but think of it like when you start a blank, fresh PM and you go to enter the person's forum name, then a list of names pops up and you can click on the name you're looking for. Then once you click their name, the PM is linked to that person).

How about that ?

Well it seems like a lot of effort to fix a problem that's not really a problem.

In my opinion, as you said the only reason the completed reports are public is to see the evidence for the warning. so why not make it so that only reports that ended with a warning will be visible? i think thats easy enough to make