Out of curiosity, why did you drop Usagi drop and put Bakuman on hold? and i'm kinda surprised to see a fan of Suzuka, the anime was alright but the manga had so much more in-depth, if you didn't read it I'd highly suggest you do that.
But hmm, Toradora, Soul Eater, 5cmps, Summer Wars, Higashi no Eden, Cowboybebop, Love hina, Myself; Yourself, Shakugan no shana, Guiltycrown, Yumekui Merry, Star Driver and Deadman wonderland are all worth looking into. I'm not sure which genres you like so I just suggested a bunch of all kinds.
My mal is:
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Sibiou but it's really disorganized at the moment, hoping to revamp it during the summer. Haven't updated it in ages lol